Showing posts with label GDP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GDP. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Q3 GDP Revised Down Again, but Lacking in Importance

Bloomberg.com reports:

The economy in the U.S. expanded in the third quarter at a slower pace than anticipated as companies curbed spending and cut inventories at an even faster pace, reductions that have set the stage for an acceleration in growth.

The 2.2 percent increase in gross domestic product from July through September compares with a 2.8 percent gain previously reported by the Commerce Department in Washington.

Improved consumer spending combined with a record drop in stockpiles this year will promote increases in production that may keep the world’s largest economy growing well into 2010. At the same time, companies such as Dell Inc. point to gains in business investment that signal growing confidence the expansion will be sustained.

“All signals point to a strong fourth quarter,” Nigel Gault, chief U.S. economist at IHS Global Insight in Lexington, Massachusetts, said before the report. “Growth is shaping up at around 4 percent as the inventory cycle turns upward.”. . .

The 2.8 percent projected pace of growth was based on the median estimate of 73 economists in a Bloomberg News survey. Estimates ranged from gains of 2.5 percent to 3.7 percent. The GDP report is the third and final for the quarter. The government’s advance estimate two months ago was 3.5 percent.

Remember that these are annualized percentages. So what has happened is the GDP growth in the quarter was estimated 2 months ago at 0.875% (3.5% divided by 4). It is now estimated at 0.55%.

I was reviewing some numbers recently and saw that GDP for 1983 had been revised recently. Perhaps those revisions are final. Basically these numbers are useless to investors or, truth be told, voters or policymakers.

The CEO of Conagra was on CNBC yesterday. Was he bullish? Yes, on his company's performance. He is budgeting for a sluggish economy. Warren Buffett recently said that his company really had not seen much of an improvement in business. The Gallup polling yesterday showed the hiring/not hiring indicator at a completely miserable negative 3.

In the quote above, Mr. Gault may well be correct. But this will mean little for the long term. The Government continues to borrow and print as much money as, I suspect, all businesses in the U. S. will show as profit this year. All this "money" injected into the pockets of seniors, poor people, agribusinessmen, Big Finance, etc. will one way or another get spent. The deleveraging risks should be to deflate prices that have gotten above the ability of wages and savings to pay for them without ever-more frantic financing schemes. That is why as gifted a stock market forecaster as Barry Ritholtz both sees more stock market gains ahead but a flat market at best on average for years to come.

No disagreement here.

Copyright (C) Long Lake LLC 2009



Thursday, August 27, 2009

GDP is More than a Gross Number

From Commerce Department's Q2 GDP report (second estimate):


Real exports of goods and services decreased 5.0 percent in the second quarter, compared with a
decrease of 29.9 percent in the first. Real imports of goods and services decreased 15.1 percent,
compared with a decrease of 36.4 percent.


Real federal government consumption expenditures and gross investment increased 11.0 percent
in the second quarter, in contrast to a decrease of 4.3 percent in the first. National defense increased
13.3 percent, in contrast to a decrease of 5.1 percent. Nondefense increased 6.2 percent, in contrast to a
decrease of 2.5 percent. Real state and local government consumption expenditures and gross
investment increased 3.6 percent, in contrast to a decrease of 1.5 percent.


The first paragraph above shows that because America's imports fell faster than exports, GDP improved (that's why it is gross domestic product). The second paragraph gets to the big problem. The ongoing wars in Asia are sucking up production (and lives); this is "unhealthy" GDP. And beyond military spending, government grew while revenues to private businesses and individuals shrank.

No free lunch . . .

Copyright (C) Long Lake LLC 2009

Friday, July 31, 2009

The Dow-Gold Ratio and the Economy


From the Chart of the Day: a long-term perspective.
This chart is misleading in that it does not include dividend income from stocks. The outperformance of stocks vs. gold from 1980-2000 was greater than shown.
I would also quarrel with the downturn trendline. I believe that too much of the past year's ratio is shown outside the major downtrend.
Given the greater than usual lack of interest in policymakers in sound money these days, I would think that the general downtrend in the Dow/Gold ratio will tend to remain in force, though it would not be surprising to see the ratio move up a bit longer as the economy is tipped to be transitioning to the classic low-inflation, healing phase following a major econonic downturn.
Absent fundamental reform of the financial system, the primacy of the bankster-gamblers that was codified by the Clinton Administration with the effective repeal of Glass-Steagall a decade ago--which correlates with the peaking of the Dow/Gold rato--continues and therefore the existing trends are likely to remain in force.
A new silver ETF, symbol SIVR, is now available. Yours truly is an owner of it. The numbers of the silver bars it owns are published daily on the Net. And sophisticated gold buyers may want to own the Canadian version of GLD, symbol GTU. Perhaps it has a bit more certainty that the gold it says it physically owns is actually there than does GLD.
Note that the GDP number released today had worse than expected consumer numbers, but the overall number was less bad than predicted because of greater government spending. But remember that GDP was actually UP in Q2 2008.
The economy has been given the equivalent of blood count booster shots that dialysis patients, who suffer from chronic anemia, receive. Neither is a sign of good health. The economy remains in poor health, cyclical changes notwithstanding.
Copyright (C) Long Lake LLC 2009

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Advance GDP Data Show Domestic Consumption Collapse

The Advance GDP data are out.  Spinmeisters will crow about the decline ending, as massive inventory reduction accounted for much of the downturn.  What will receive little publicity is the following, taken from the BEA Press Release (www.bea.gov, see "Latest Release"):

Real gross domestic purchases - - purchases by U. S. residents of goods and services wherever produced - - decreased 7.8% in the first quarter, compared with a decrease of 5.9% in the fourth.

This shows a true collapse in domestic consumption.  My quick explanation is that imports collapsed 34% while the smaller quantity of exports collapsed less, at 30%.  Thus the country enjoyed a significant diminution in its share of the world's goods and services (consistent with the need to start running trade surpluses).   The implication appears to be that consumers could not afford imported goods.

Please recall that GDP relates to domestic production.  As a reductio ad absurdum, if the U. S. became a colony of another country and produced only for export except for food and water etc., GDP could grow and grow but the American people would not see any of that production.
So what good is GDP?  That's a good question.

Stock market futures are up on the GDP report.  They are also reportedly experiencing a relief rally that the swine flu pandemic is not as bad as SARS, or some other thought of the day.  This blog advised readers on April 27 to more or less ignore the swine flu news in their investing activities.  This pandemic is a non-trivial problem, but there is no way EBR sees to profit from it.  Overall it is obviously bad for worldwide economies, so on a short-term basis, it is a negative for stocks, but over the long run (which is what stock prices are supposed to discount)
what we see now is unlikely to have major macro effects on the economy of the world.

In the meantime, all the money-printing is converting bears to bulls.  Yet as Louise Yamada points out, there is no real leadership, unlike 1982, when long-suffering groups such as consumer goods showed real relative strength all throughout the 1981-2 bear market and had long bases from which long advances began when the bear market ended.  In contrast, leaders of one year ago, such as gold and oil, are going nowhere, and the high-quality Dow leaders of 2008, WMT and MCD, have stock charts that are becalmed.

Fitting that theme, a recent report found "millionaires" more confused than ever as to where to put their funds.  Increased interest in investing in both stocks and bonds was reported.  Meanwhile, a recent poll of money managers showed only about 4% bulls on Treasuries.  Louise Yamada has pinpointed about 3.1% on the 10-year Treasury as a recent top in yields, which corresponds exactly to the low yield in the prior cycle (2001-3), and therefore feels it may represent support in price/resistance in yield.  Given that mortgage-backed securities are now a bit rich historically vs. Treasuries, a trade from the former to the latter may be of interest.

Copyright (C) Long Lake LLC 2009

 

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Thursday Evening Potpourri

Here are some snippets from articles and blog posts from the past day, with comments.  My takeaway from them is consistent with my conclusion from last night's post, which is that somehow, despite a Dow that is south of 8000, the bulls are feeling frisky.  Let's hope they are correct!

U.S. Economy: GDP Slumps 6.3% Before Possible ‘Turning Point’ 

By Shobhana Chandra

March 26 (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. economy shrank at a 6.3 percent annual pace in the fourth quarter, the worst performance since 1982, in what may be the depths of the recession.

The contraction in gross domestic product was larger than the previously estimated 6.2 percent drop, the Commerce Department said today in Washington. A report from the Labor Department showed the number of people collecting jobless benefit this month climbed to a record 5.56 million.

“We’re at a turning point,” Michael Darda, chief economist at MKM Partners LP in Greenwich, Connecticut, said in an interview with Bloomberg Radio. “There are some glimmers of hope. By the fourth quarter, maybe even the third quarter, we’ll be pleasantly surprised by the economic data.”

Recent reports show retail sales, residential construction and home sales have improved, indicating last quarter’s slump may give way to smaller declines in growth. A let-up in the recession would set the stage for President Barack Obama’s stimulus plan and Federal Reserve measures to take hold in the second half of the year.

Stocks climbed, extending the biggest monthly rally since 1987, on mounting speculation the economy may be past the worst of the downturn. 


Comment:  Being past the worst of the downturn is both unlikely, per the ECRI weekly leading indicators; and almost irrelevant to the stock market.  For example, see (from where, I forget!):


Both the new and old fourth-quarter GDP readings were the worst since the first quarter of 1982, when the economy, hit by a severe recession, contracted at a 6.4 percent pace.


Comment:  Let us say that the economy will now contract more slowly than the 6.3% annual rate reported for Q4 2008.  Clearly in 1982, a 6.4% represented the bottom, though the economy stayed in recession into 1983.  When did the stock market bottom in 1982?  Was it in the first quarter, when the pace of recession weakened?  No.  Was it in the second quarter?  No.  It was actually halfway through the third quarter, in August 1982, when the Fed loosened their tight money policy to rescue Mexico.  Stocks soared, as did zero coupon bonds.  If one was safely invested in bonds, as I was, there was no rush to get into stocks (though I did rush in immediately, where I stayed for the next 18 years).  

By analogy, there is now no rush to buy stocks even if the pace of the economic decline has seen its worst.


What's going on fundamentally?  Here's a factual but non-cheery data point:


March 26 (Bloomberg) -- JPMorgan Chase & Co. will delay contributions to 401(k) retirement plans for salaried employees until the end of the year and may reduce the payments, according to a person who received a company memo on the changes. . .

U.S. companies are cutting back matching contributions to employee retirement plans to save cash, and the trend is growing, according to a survey by Spectrem Group. The survey of 150 U.S. companies found that 34 percent have reduced or eliminated retirement-plan contributions since January 2008. In the next 12 months, 29 percent intend to scale back or eliminate their match, the survey showed.

At least 148 U.S. employers have stopped or reduced 401(k) matching contributions since June 2008, including General Motors Corp., Eastman Kodak Co., Motorola Inc., Sears Holdings Corp. Hewlett-Packard Co. and Xerox Corp., according to the Pension Rights Center, which is pushing for retirement savings alternatives to the 401(k).

Comment:  So, if you are working for JPMorgan Chase, which allegedly is the strongest of the "big four" mega-financial companies still standing (AIG, Fannie/Freddie not really standing), and you see this A) sign of financial weakness by your employer and B) hit to your retirement, are you going to A) spend more or B) save more?  (No prize for the right answer, in keeping with the New Frugality . . .)

The same not only goes for employees of Hewlett-Packard, which supposedly is doing well, but for employees of almost every company that has not (yet) cut back on its pension contribution.
Somehow it just doesn't seem likely that Americans are, tomorrow or the next day, about to become free spenders again.  Au contraire.

Next:

The Nasdaq Composite is the first of the major three U.S. indices to blow the all-clear whistle, it seems. It touched being flat year-to-date today, which is fairly remarkable considering it hit its low not even a month ago. Granted, it never plummeted as far as the Dow and the S&P 500 -- it helps not to have financials in your index -- but its ascent has still been fairly remarkable.

Comment:  The above, from the estimable Paul Kedrosky at his Infectious Greed blog, is one in a series of recently bullish comments from an admitted bear.  Note the language, which implicitly suggests that the author believes that the other major indices (Dow 30 and S&P 500) will follow to breakeven at least.  He could just as properly have said somberly:  "The 'NAZ', that hotbed of speculative froth that only bothers to pay a dividend when, as with Microsoft, everyone and his brother knows that the company is no longer a growth vehicle, struggled back to breakeven on the year, even though broader and more important indices remain mired in negative territory, and all these indices have been horrible performers for investors on any time frame you care to name up to a dozen years."  But he didn't phrase it that way at all. 
Further comment on the comment:  This suggests to me that more and more bears have capitulated, having been worn out by the lengthy bear market, and that they are looking past the bottom.  
Further comment etc.:  How an index getting to neutral in any way sounds an "all-clear whistle" is a confusing concept.  

Next, from Barry Ritholtz's "The Big Picture" blog, is a skewering of the MSM's interpretation of the latest housing data.  Mr. Ritholtz has published some of the most incisive comments on the housing bubble for years.  He begins his post with the following quotes, then comments (all from him in italics).

WSJ: Sales of new homes rose in February for the first time in seven months, the Commerce Department reported Wednesday, another sign that the housing market is thawing

Bloomberg: Purchases of new homes in the U.S. unexpectedly rose in February from a record low as plummeting prices and cheaper mortgage rates lured some buyers. Sales increased 4.7 percent to an annual pace of 337,000 . . .

Marketwatch: The U.S. housing sector continues to see signs of improvement. The latest government data showed new home sales climbed in February for the first time in seven months, sending shares of home-building companies soaring. . .

(Ritholtz now writing):  Note that the month over month data at 4.7% — plus or minus 18.3% — is statistically insignificant. (i.e., meaningless). The reported data does not inform us if sales improved month-over-month or not. It is a range, from down -13.6% to plus 23%. Since “zero” is part of that range, we can draw no conclusion. As the Census Department itself notes, “the change is not statistically significant; that is, it is uncertain whether there was an increase or decrease.”

The data does however, tell us that the year-over-year sales fell 41.1% plus or minus 7.9% gives us a range of -49% to -33.2%. The entire range is negative, therefore we can conclude sales fell year-over-year.

These are facts. This is data. This is how you interpret it. Most of the MSM reports (WSJ, Marketwatch, Bloomberg) were simply wrong. . .

(Ritholtz again (bolding his point)):  Let me remind (Ed:  you) that many of these folks incorrectly misinformed you that Housing wasn’t getting worse in 2006, 2007 and 2008 — just as Home sales and prices went into an historic freefall. Now, these same folks are misinforming you that Housing has turned around and is improving. That is simply unsupported by the data.

Comment from DoctoRx now:  Good for Barry.  The housing stocks peaked in spring 2005.  The market knew bad times were coming.  That it took 4 years from the stock peak for housing starts to finally go low enough to allow inventory to begin to align with demand is horrifying.  It would be a real failure of the free market - except that there is no free market in housing.  Rather, demand is artificially pumped up in a variety of ways.

Finally, a comment on what is happening in America (from a suscription-only site):

Third Willed

Emanuel Derman | Mar 26, 2009

I was reading Yahoo Finance and came across the following Associated Press release:

"Democrats are looking for a way to respond to the public's outrage over taxpayer money being used to bankroll big bonuses for financial executives without alienating an industry whose cooperation is crucial to the nation's economic recovery.The House Financial Services Committee planned to endorse on Thursday a bill that would let Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner and financial regulators decide whether an institution was spending too much money rewarding its employees.

The measure would exempt institutions that agree to participate in a government-sponsored program aimed at buying up $1 trillion of bad debt, or "toxic assets," sitting on the books of major banks. Geithner proposed the new investment program on Monday."

This is the third-world stuff that dreams are Madoff: the threat that if you are not a GSE (Geithner Sponsored Enterprise) you will not be exempt from arbitrary legislation.

Comment:  The above Derman post states that he is from South Africa; he knows what it's like to live in a third-world regime.

That's enough for now, methinks . . .


Copyright (C) Long Lake LLC 2009

Friday, February 27, 2009

Domestic Product Gross

The Commerce Department has just released its "preliminary" GDP data for Q4 2008. The numbers are bad and much worse than the milder downturn suggested by the "advance" GDP numbers a month ago.

Far be it from anyone to suggest that there is a trend here, which is to soften up people's views of the economy by letting out a bad number and then revising it downward.

If you are interested in receiving Government economic reports directly, without the filter of the MSM, it is easy. You can simply go to www.economicindicators.gov and sign up for free Email dissemination of the data. You may see the numbers before the President!

One day the news will be good, and it may even be truthfully good. For now, the bad news on the economy and the fundamental lack of real asset support for stocks continue to make the basic trend of the stock market lower till proven otherwise.

Copyright (C) Long Lake LLC 2009